A score in the low 90s would be outstanding for most games. For Grand Theft Auto, some fans may treat it as a setback.
The first GTA 6 reviews will face an unusual problem. They will be judged not only on what Rockstar has built but on the reputation of five celebrated games that arrived before it. Metacritic scores for Grand Theft Auto III, Vice City, San Andreas, IV and V sit within a remarkably narrow band, from 95 to 98 on the relevant versions. Few long-running series have sustained that kind of critical record.
The implication is awkward. A new release could receive excellent reviews and still be described as falling short. That says something about the strength of the franchise, but also about the way score comparisons distort a more complicated judgment. A number is useful context. It is not the whole review.
A five-game benchmark that most studios never reach
Grand Theft Auto III earned a 97 Metacritic score, while Vice City and San Andreas reached 95. Grand Theft Auto IV scored 98, and Grand Theft Auto V reached 97 on its original major console release. These scores reflect critical aggregation on particular platforms, not an eternal ranking across every later port and edition.
Taken together, they create an expectation that a GTA release will be more than competent. Reviewers have repeatedly praised the franchise’s ability to combine large environments, memorable characters and a distinctive satirical voice. Players now expect GTA 6 to modernise those strengths without losing the elements that made the older games memorable.
What has changed since GTA V?
Grand Theft Auto V arrived in 2013. In the years since, open-world games have expanded in scale and variety. Some now feature deeper role-playing systems; others specialise in authored storytelling or demanding combat. Meanwhile, technical expectations for animation, accessibility, performance and post-launch support have risen sharply.
Rockstar therefore faces a less forgiving comparison than a simple graphics contest. A beautifully rendered city can still disappoint if missions feel repetitive or controls fight against the player. Equally, a game with minor technical flaws can become a landmark because its world and characters linger in memory. Review scores compress these different judgments into one number.
The danger of treating 95 as a pass mark
In most critical contexts, a Metacritic score above 90 suggests broad acclaim. Yet discussion around GTA 6 may convert a 94 into a controversy because it sits below earlier entries. That framing would reward a simplistic historical comparison over close reading of the individual reviews.
The best questions are more specific. Does Vice City feel alive beyond scripted missions? Does the relationship between Jason and Lucia carry the story? Are the game’s systems coherent? How does the PS5 experience compare with the Xbox version? Those answers matter more to a prospective buyer than a tiny difference between aggregate scores.
Reviews may not arrive all at once
Large releases sometimes stagger access to review copies and impose embargoes. Platform testing, patch timing and the length of a sprawling campaign can complicate the process. An early aggregate may shift as more publications submit their verdicts. Players should check the review count and platform represented before sharing a score as definitive.
User scores require separate judgment. They can capture audience sentiment, but early voting can also be affected by technical frustrations, organised campaigns or people who have not finished the game. Professional reviews are imperfect too; their advantage is that they provide a detailed argument readers can evaluate.
Commercial success and critical acclaim are different stories
The financial momentum behind Grand Theft Auto VI is already enormous, though pre-order estimates circulating in the media are not the same as independently audited sales figures. Rockstar’s established audience may make launch sales resilient even if critics disagree over individual features.
That should not make reviews irrelevant. A thoughtful negative assessment can identify a real problem, and strong criticism can prompt a studio to address performance or usability concerns. The mistake is assuming every score below a predecessor’s number represents a decline in quality. Different games, eras and review pools produce different averages.
Scores also reflect the review environment
A game’s aggregate can be influenced by which outlets publish during a particular window and which platform versions they test. An ambitious open world may draw praise for exploration while receiving criticism for accessibility or performance. Neither finding cancels the other. Readers can gain more from identifying the recurring strengths and weaknesses than by arguing about whether a rating should be 94 or 96. The individual review offers reasoning; the average offers a shortcut. Both can inform a purchase, but they serve different purposes.
How to read the verdicts when they land
Start with the text rather than the headline number. Look for repeated findings across outlets, especially on performance, mission design, storytelling and the value of exploration. Separate concerns that affect all players from preferences tied to particular genres or play styles.
There is a good chance GTA 6 will be evaluated against history more aggressively than almost any other release this year. The healthiest approach is to treat the old scores as evidence of a demanding legacy, not as a mathematical requirement. Rockstar’s newest game deserves to be understood on its own terms.